May 24, 2018 - Read Time: 1 Minute

You might find more complicated strawberry recipes, but not will be better tasting than this old recipe from Sunset Magazine. Grab your strawberries, make a crust or buy one, but do have a slice!

American Strawberry Pie
Serves 6
Our favorite way for strawberry pie - American style
Prep Time
40 min
Prep Time
40 min
  1. Pre baked pie shell of your choice 9.5-10 inches in diameter, 1.5 inch side
  2. 4 cups strawberries, sliced in half
  3. 1 cup caster sugar
  4. 9 gr sheet gelatin or 1 tbs powdered gelatin
  5. 1 cup water
  1. Soften sheet gelatin in water or dissolve powdered gelatin in 1/4 cup water
  2. Cook 3/4 cup of the strawberries in 1 cup of water until they are soft.
  3. Strain the strawberries back into the water so that you get a thin puree.
  4. Add the 1 cup of sugar and stir until sugar is dissolved.
  5. Add the gelatin of your choice, (wring out sheet gelatin if using that)
  6. Chill a bit until just barely cool and syrupy.
  7. Fold this liquid into the strawberries.
  8. Pour into pie shell and chill until the gelatin is set.
  9. Serve with whipped cream
  1. I add a small amount of natural strawberry essence from France into the strawberries as our strawberries here are not very flavorful.
Adapted from Sunset Magazine
Adapted from Sunset Magazine
Kitchen Detail

Tags: ,


  • Tarah F Taylor says:

    Can you tell me the name of the French company that makes the essences the store used to carry?
    Thank you,

    • Hi Tarah,
      It was a group of companies but they currently do not have distribution at the consumer level in the US. I am working with a wholesale distributor to see if there is a way for small consumers to purchase them in the US.


      • Jeffrey Huisman says:

        Thank you, Nancy, for working to try to bring those essences back to the US market. I just found your store had closed as I was getting ready for my annual restocking. I will miss your store immensely and I have no idea how I’ll replace the flavors I’ve used so liberally in my cooking for the last 12 or more years. Here’s to hoping!

  • Tarah F Taylor says:

    Thanks so much! Keep us posted!!!!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Follow this link to create a Kitchen Detail account so that you can leave comments!